Turn the queries sitting just off Google’s first page into a short, justified list of pages to improve, and check whether the change worked.
You open Search Console and find hundreds of queries averaging position 11 to 20. A few are worth an afternoon of work. Most are not.
Here is how to sort them: which page to improve, why, and how you will know it worked.
The short version. Keep a page-two query only if it matters to your business, the right page ranks for it, your page matches what searchers want, and its position is stable. Then change one page at a time and check clicks, not just position.
What “page two” means in the data
Search Console’s average position is the topmost position your site held for a query, averaged across the times it was shown (Google). So an average of 14 can hide days at 6 and days at 30, and results pages are not always ten plain links. Treat 11–20 as a band of near misses, not a literal second page.
Step 1 · Pull the list
- In Search Console, open the Performance report, show Average position and use a three-month range (Google).
- On the Queries table, export it and filter positions 11–20 in a spreadsheet. Then open each query’s Pages tab to see which URL ranks.
- Keep impressions beside each row: a query at 12 with 20 impressions changes nothing.
In Ndovu, Search Performance does the first cut: Opportunities → Push to top 3 lists queries at positions 4–20 with the extra clicks each could bring, estimated from your own click-through rate at each position. Movements → On page 2 shows which queries moved into or out of the band.
Step 2 · Ask six questions of each query
| Question | Keep it when | Drop or park it when |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Does it matter to the business? | People searching it could buy, enquire or book. | It brings readers you can’t serve. |
| 2. Which page ranks? | It is the page you’d want to land on. | A blog post, a sold listing or the homepage ranks instead of the right page. |
| 3. Does the page match the search? | The results page shows the same kind of page as yours. | Searchers get tools, videos or a different type of page. |
| 4. Is the position stable? | It has sat in the band for weeks. | It jumps around or appeared last week. |
| 5. Is there enough demand? | Impressions are meaningful for your site. | A handful of impressions over three months. |
| 6. Is it branded? | It is a non-branded discovery search. | It already names you; work on it separately. |
Example: a used-car marketplace
Illustrative example, not real data. An invented Kenyan used-car marketplace, three months of Search Console data.
| Query | Ranking page | Avg. position | Impressions | Who searches | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| toyota fielder for sale nairobi | /cars/toyota/fielder/ | 12.4 | 2,400 | Buyers | Improve the model page. |
| mazda demio price in kenya | /cars/mazda/demio/ | 14.1 | 3,100 | Buyers checking prices | Improve: add a current price table. |
| best fuel efficient cars in kenya | /blog/fuel-saving-tips/ | 17.8 | 1,900 | Researchers | New page: a comparison guide, not a stretched tips post. |
| toyota prado 2015 for sale | /listing/prado-2015-…/ (sold) | 11.9 | 600 | Buyers | Improve /cars/toyota/prado/ and link to it from listings. |
| mercedes c200 for sale mombasa | /cars/mercedes-benz/c200/ | 15.2 | 450 | Buyers in Mombasa | Check stock: only if you list cars there. |
| car import duty calculator kenya | /blog/import-duty-explained/ | 13.5 | 5,200 | Importers | Investigate: results show calculators; that is a product decision. |
| how to check logbook kenya | /blog/logbook-transfer/ | 16.4 | 1,300 | Owners | Leave: weak link to selling cars. |
| car | Homepage | 18.0 | 9,000 | Everyone | Leave: too broad to win or convert. |
Page-two queries by impressions, and the decision on each
- Improve or new page
- Check first
- Leave
Search Console impressions over three months for each query, with its average position. The two largest are not the best opportunities.
Source: Illustrative example: invented figures, not real data.
Result: four pages to improve (Fielder, Demio, Prado and, if stock allows, C200), one new guide to plan, one product question and two queries to leave. The biggest impression counts — “car” and the calculator — are not the best opportunities.
Step 3 · Change the page, one at a time
- Match the search. Look at what ranks above you and give the searcher what they came for: stock, prices, a comparison or an answer.
- Name it clearly. Put the specifics in the title and H1. Google may still build its title link from other parts of the page, so keep the visible heading consistent (Google).
- Link to it. Add links from related pages with descriptive anchor text, such as from each Prado listing to the Prado page.
- Don’t compete with yourself. If two of your pages split one query, improve one and point the other to it, rather than adding a third.
- Check the basics. The page is indexable, its canonical points to itself, and it loads well on mobile.
Step 4 · Track it and check the result
- Write down the change and its date.
- Track a few of the queries in rank tracking, with the right country or city and device.
- After four weeks, compare the same query and page with the four weeks before. Look at clicks and impressions, not just position: an average can rise while clicks don’t.
- If nothing moved, check the page was recrawled before changing it again.
In Ndovu, click Mark done on the opportunity; 28 days later Movements → Did your fixes work? judges it Worked, No change, Fell or Gone. For a change across many pages, SEO tests compare them with a control group.
A worksheet you can copy
Query:
Ranking page:
Avg. position (period):
Impressions (period):
What the results page shows:
Business relevance:
Decision (improve / new page / investigate / leave):
Change made, and date:
Check on (date):
Result (clicks and position, same period length):
| When you need to… | Read |
|---|---|
| Use Opportunities and Movements | Read the Search Performance report |
| Track the queries you chose | Track keyword rankings |
| Pick a rank tracker | Best rank tracking software in Kenya |
| Understand position in different tools | First-party SEO data vs market estimates |
Sources
- Search Console: impressions, position and clicks
- Search Console: Performance report
- Google: Influencing title links